All Discussion
DISCUSSION
 
D:1RP ( 5639.51 points)October 31, 2017 02:32pm
All 50 Senate approval polls: [Link]

 
Joker:9757BrentinCO ( 9685.29 points)November 09, 2018 08:20pm
Turning to the 2020 elections, I’m guessing the top Senate targets for Dems are Collins (ME) and Gardner (CO) with maybe Tillis (NC) and Ernst (IA) following behind.

For Republicans is obviously Jones (AL) with Shaheen (NH) and Warner (VA).

Doesn’t seem like alot of competitive races unless we get retirements out of Roberts (KS) and Lamar (TN) which would probably still favor th GOP.

Thoughts?

 
D:8509DylanSH99 ( 1737.91 points)November 09, 2018 09:21pm
I agree with you, Collins will be the top target for the Democrats. You think maybe Bredesen will try again in TN?

 
D:1989RBH ( 5694.97 points)November 09, 2018 11:15pm
We might forget that Arizona is back on the board for 2020 (the seat vacated by McCain's death).

But my board is..

Arizona (Stanton or Kirkpatrick) / Colorado (Jason Crow or Perlmutter) top two

Then a few where the hope is that 2 of them stick

Georgia (One of the random kids from 2014 [Carter/Nunn] or Ossoff or whoever, not sure if McBath can run and have Ds retain her seat)

Iowa (I think Ds would have a better shot of retaining an open IA03 than open IA01, or have Hubbell run against Ernst too)

Maine (Pingree vs Susan Collins, I suspect Collins voting record will veer left with 53 Rs in the Senate and her re-elect coming up. If Collins retires, it's a pickup)

North Carolina (exhume Brad Miller from wherever he went since 2012? maybe voters get amped for Larry Kissell or Dan McCready? bring back Deb Ross?)

Texas (Try to ride a wave against the less notable Texas Senator? Hope that Andrew White doesn't lose a primary this time?)

I'd think that Kansas/Tennessee won't make the board even with a retirement. Unless Kris Kobach wins the nomination to replace Roberts. In that case, the local equivalent to Travis Childers would need to be kept ready since they can't just replace a nominee.

States like Kentucky, West Virginia (only if Moore Capito decides to bail after a term for whatever reason), Nebraska (if Sasse gets primaried by a nut) or Montana (if Bullock runs) are long shots.

I think Alabama flips back to the Rs. Short of a total disaster in their nomination process again.

The Republican effort in New Hampshire would involve trying to get Sununu against Shaheen. If he goes for a third term, then they go to Ayotte. If neither runs, they're kinda way behind there. Unless they get Gatsas or someone to take the spot.

Virginia is a state that is sorta sprinting away from Rs. They haven't won a statewide race there since 2009 and those three Rs haven't had a great last decade.

Ds need 3 net pickups and a Presidential win to get a majority. Barring some miracle outcome in Florida or something that flips an unexpected seat from R to D in the next 2 years. If Nelson had won (I think trailing by 5 digits isn't particularly likely to win via recount).. then it's 2 seats and the Presidency which is much more doable with the 2020 lineup.

 
D:7CA Pol Junkie ( 5449.93 points)November 10, 2018 12:32am
The general environment is more likely to be favorable to Democrats again. Either unpopular Trump is running for re-election or the Republican Party is split. The economy won't be stronger than it is now, and could be considerably worse.

ME, AZ, CO, IA, and NC will be targets for Democrats, obviously they will lose AL and Republicans will try for NH. It's at least a more favorable map for Democrats than they had this year.

 
D:6086Jason ( 13474.04 points)November 10, 2018 12:49pm
I dunno, I think Donald Trump is going to kick our asses. Our bench of Presidential contenders is weak and the party has done nothing to rebuild its standing in the rust belt or to change the electoral map to compensate.

That being said, the Senate side should be better just based purely on the numbers. 2014 went about as badly as it possibly could, so there are limited options for the GOP to make gains beyond Alabama.

 
Joker:9757BrentinCO ( 9685.29 points)November 10, 2018 05:50pm
RBH: Colorado (Jason Crow or Perlmutter) top two

Good analysis. On CO, I’ve been thinking Perlmutter is getting tired of the House and looking for a change (as evidenced by his contemplation of running for Governor). Two other strong contendors to your list would be Joe Neguese and former Speaker Crisanta Duran. Given the blue wave that hit Colorado this year, I’m sure there will be no shortage of Democrats thinking about jumping in.

 
I:6738IndyGeorgia ( 4881.18 points)January 10, 2019 08:40pm
116th Congress Committee Assignments:

Republicans: [Link]
Democrats: [Link]

 
I:1038WA Indy ( 1821.84 points)April 25, 2022 02:17pm
I doubt they'd vote for him if he ran again in 2024, but Manchin's voting over the last year and some change has gained him popularity among GOP voters in WV.

[Link]

 
WASH:8766Pennsylvanian ( 406.19 points)April 28, 2022 06:47am
That he has drawn the ire of the more progressive wing, the likes of AOC and The Squad, has no doubt been of great benefit to him. It's a smart political play on his part. Seems to me the more vocal the progressives are in their outright disdain for Manchin, the stronger he becomes.

 
R:250Mr. Politics ( 190.17 points)July 11, 2022 07:03am
Rank these Senate races in order of most to least likely to be won by the Democrats in November: AZ, CO, GA, NV, NH, NC, OH, PA, WI.

 
D:1RP ( 5639.51 points)July 11, 2022 07:33am
NH, CO, AZ, GA, PA, NV, WI, OH, NC

 
D:6086Jason ( 13474.04 points)July 11, 2022 09:59am
CO, NH, NV, AZ, PA, GA, OH, WI, NC.

 
I:9951E Pluribus Unum ( -256.32 points)July 11, 2022 11:52am
PA, CO, NH, NV, GA, AZ, WI, NC, OH

 
I:1038WA Indy ( 1821.84 points)July 11, 2022 12:29pm
CO, NH, AZ, PA, NV, GA, WI, OH, NC

Nothing against Masto, but from what little I've seen of her she has the charisma of a paper bag and Laxalt, while he'd fall in line 98% of the time while presenting himself as a rational moderate, doesn't come off as an offensive candidate.

Fetterman may as well be an incumbent at this point. He's not going to runaway with it or get Casey margins but I have a hard time seeing him lose.

It's sad that Georgia is a toss-up, but tons of Republicans would vote for a dead dog if it had a Trump endorsement.

If this were the 90s, I'd have OH before WI, but unless Ryan proves to have some crossover appeal in a red state, it ain't happening. The last 5 will all be heartbreakingly close, but I don't see them flipping at the moment.

 
D:7CA Pol Junkie ( 5449.93 points)July 11, 2022 03:56pm
According to polling data, the strongest negative reaction to the Dobbs decision was among the college-educated. We don't know how much it will affect the results but I suspect it will push CO and NH out of reach for Republicans and make NC more competitive for Democrats.

 
Joker:9757BrentinCO ( 9685.29 points)July 11, 2022 11:34pm
NH, CO, AZ, NV, PA, GA, WI, NC, OH

Strong Confidence in NH, CO, AZ going to Democrats

NV, PA probably going to Democrats

GA, WI true tossups

NC close by likely Republican

OH will tease Democrats for a few more months then in October start looking like a total blowout.

 
WmP:879Chronicler ( 84.45 points)July 12, 2022 07:15am
Maybe I will share a little about Pennsylvania. Some Republicans are unhappy with Oz's primary win. One Republican told me she won't vote for Oz since he is Muslim. I don't know what fraction of Republicans think that way or if it will make a difference.

I know that EPU is a big Fetterman supporter. I have seen Fetterman in various capacities, going back to the debates in 2018. He may make a fine Senator, but I doubt he will "fix" the Senate like his ads claim.

At this point I think Fetterman will likely win in the 5-7% range. It's possible that Ronald Johnson will skim off 5% of the Republican vote that would otherwise have made this race tight.

 
Joker:9757BrentinCO ( 9685.29 points)July 12, 2022 06:04pm
I don't think Barnette has endorsed Oz yet and is still giving him the cold shoulder. Wondering if she will cause problems for Oz in PA.

 
WmP:879Chronicler ( 84.45 points)August 19, 2022 06:49pm
I don't know how the midterms will play out. At least for now the polls show the Democrats rising nearly everywhere. The current Democratic seats in Georgia, Nevada, New Hampshire, and Arizona look stronger than two months ago. Democratic challengers are rising in Ohio, Florida, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Iowa, and North Carolina. The best news the Republicans have is an outside shot of winning in Colorado and the fact that Walker finally placed first in a Georgia poll. If this holds, it will be an important footnote in midterm history.

 
R:250Mr. Politics ( 190.17 points)October 07, 2022 03:06pm
From the Dems' perspective, I think the Senate goes like this at this point:

44. Connecticut
45. Washington
46. Colorado
47. New Hampshire
48. Arizona
49. Pennsylvania
50. Georgia
51. Nevada
52. Wisconsin
53. Ohio
54. North Carolina
55. Florida
56. Missouri
57. Utah

Other people thoughts?

 
D:1RP ( 5639.51 points)October 07, 2022 03:10pm
Seems about right to me.

 
Joker:9757BrentinCO ( 9685.29 points)October 07, 2022 04:48pm
I'm still suspect of OH polls. It might be NC @ 53 and OH @ 54 for me - meaning I believe NC will be easier to pick off for Dems than OH.

More recent statewide victories for Ds in NC than OH.

 
MKKP:11457The Fixer ( 53.61 points)November 11, 2022 06:28pm